Defense vows appeal of Valentine’s Day murder conviction
Defense attorneys will appeal Maurice Johnson’s conviction and sentence of life without parole for his role in the 1999 Valentine’s Day Cleveland triple murder.
Mitchell Bryant, co-counsel for Mr. Johnson, said Tuesday afternoon he and his co-counsel, Steven Ward, will file an appeal after Judge Amy Reedy sentences his client on a related conviction for especially aggravated robbery charge
Mr. Bryant said he was disappointed the jury found his client guilty Monday on three counts of first-degree murder for the Feb. 14, 1999, slayings of O.J. Blair, 18; Cayci Higgins, 19; and Dawn Rogers, 25.
Prosecutors alleged that Mr. Johnson and co-defendant Michael Younger broke down tiffany jewelry the back door at 431 19th St., bound the three victims’ hands behind their backs and shot them in the backs of their heads as they knelt on the floor.
The jury on Monday convicted Mr. Johnson evening after about six hours of deliberation and took three hours Tuesday to decide on the sentence. They could have chosen the death penalty or life with parole.
Teri Walters, niece of Ms. Rogers, spoke to the jury in what’s known as a victim impact statement before they began deliberating Mr. Johnson’s sentence.
“I tried to let them know how much she loved her children,” Ms. Walters said. She emphasized all of the milestones her aunt would miss — birthdays, graduations, weddings and other special events.
Ms. Walters said it was hard to influence someone to choose a death sentence because that has to be an individual decision.
But she said Mr. Johnson’s life sentence will still allow him to see his family, even if it’s through glass.
“He’ll still get to experience milestones with his children,” she said.
Ms. Rogers won’t see her children grow, she said.
Despite the pain she feels for her family’s loss, she said, she still feels sympathy for Mr. Johnson’s family.
Richard Fisher, who was co-prosecutor with Paul Moyle, said the district attorney’s office and silver bangles especially Cleveland police detective Duff Brumley’s tenacious efforts investigating the case were what made the conviction possible.
Mr. Younger and Twanna “Tart” Blair also are charged in the case and face the death penalty.
Mr. Fisher said he and the defense attorneys for Ms. Blair are to meet with Judge Reedy on Friday to set a date for her trial. No date is set for Mr. Younger’s trial.